Update to this post: the new version of Stanza now allows full copy and paste from a single ereader screen to another app. Yay Stanza, and thank you!
—
I’m one of those weird people who prefer reading to listening to music, to playing video games, to, in many cases, watching movies. Reading ranks just below walking in the woods and far above dance parties. So when I got an iPhone, I was one of the weirdos who didn’t give a damn about Shazam, or Twittering my mundanity, or waving around a glowing screen that sounded like a light saber. I downloaded eReaders. As many as were available for free, and a few that were not.
Stanza is by far the best eReader, in my opinion, and it improves with every release. Amazon Kindle for iPhone, however, has the selection Stanza lacks. Kindle for iPhone lameness begins with the words themselves: you cannot change the font to sans-serif (a better font for on-screen reading, Amazon, in case you didn’t know that yet, though you must, because you are Web folks, in which case, you are just doing it to annoy iPhone users for not purchasing a Kindle, which is lame).
All that aside, my bone of contention with every single eReader available, and, therefore with the iPhone in general, is that because I cannot copy text from an eReader and paste it into Notes, or some other app that can send email, or sync with my laptop, my notes are just as proprietary as the book I’m reading or the eReader I’m using. I’m stuck trying to highlight or add notes in the Kindle for iPhone interface. On occasion, the app crashes, and if I haven’t recently quit it normally, an hour’s worth of notes and highlights are gone when it starts up again. This is not a sane way to prepare a book review.
I can understand why preventing copy and paste would make sense to publishers and eReader developers alike. No one wants me to copy all and then email the whole text of the book to all of my friends. But if texts on eReaders are going to be of value to intellectuals, if they are going to be of more value than print on paper, then developers and marketers will have to give me the only thing I really, truly want in an eReader: the possibility of streamlining the annotation/note-taking workflow by being able to copy small portions of text and paste them into any text editor.
There are easy ways to do this without allowing me to copy the entire text. Allow copy and paste of a limited word count, for example. Allow me to export my highlights and notes, or email them. While the publishers and developers dissolve into a bubbling puddle of DRM craziness, students and academics are retyping passages which they wish to annotate or quote in a paper or article from one electronic device to another. This is ludicrous.
I’m not surprised that Kindle would do this, because they like to yank books people have already purchased off their devices without notifying them. But the fact that it’s all eReader apps available for iPhone means it’s an Apple policy. That’s too bad, because we’re denying users the one thing that could be really useful about books in electronic format.
Let’s look at it like this: you may own the trademark on the device or app, the rights to distribute the book, the patent on the double-click, whatever, but you do not own my personal thoughts about the text, and I should be able to copy small portions of a book I have legally purchased onto other applications, like text editors, without having to rekey those passages.
Otherwise, let’s face it, what’s the use of having an eBook at all? Print on paper is a pretty great technology. It’s durable, not fragile, and much more energy-efficient than an iPhone. Stanza, Kindle, iPhone, can you wow me already? Is this all ya’ got?